$9(5¶<$129$ꢅꢃꢃ6(92',1ꢃ
ꢀꢁꢀꢑꢃ
PHWKDQROVꢃZLWKꢃFRPSOH[ꢃPHWDOꢃK\GULGHVꢃ>ꢂꢅꢃꢑ@ꢉꢃ&RPꢋ
ꢋꢅ&KORURꢅꢌꢅSKHQ\OꢅꢊꢉꢌꢅGLK\GURꢅꢄ+ꢅꢈꢉꢊꢅEHQ]ꢅ
SRXQGVꢃ,,DꢃDQGꢃ,,EꢃZHUHꢃREWDLQHGꢃLQꢃJRRGꢃ\LHOGꢃE\ꢃ R[D]LQꢅꢄꢅRQHꢀꢃ,,,Dꢆꢁꢃ<LHOGꢃꢈꢁ;ꢅꢃPSꢃꢀꢒꢄ±ꢀꢒꢈ&ꢊꢃSXEꢋ
OLVKHGꢃGDWDꢃ>ꢄ@ꢏꢃPSꢃꢀꢒꢀ±ꢀꢒꢌ&ꢉꢃ
UHGXFWLRQꢃRIꢃRꢋDPLQREHQ]RSKHQRQHVꢃ,DꢃDQGꢃ,EꢃZLWKꢃ
VRGLXPꢃWHWUDK\GULGRERUDWHꢉꢃ
ꢋꢅ1LWURꢅꢌꢅSKHQ\OꢅꢊꢉꢌꢅGLK\GURꢅꢄ+ꢅꢈꢉꢊꢅEHQ]R[Dꢅ
]LQꢅꢄꢅRQHꢀꢃ,,,Eꢆꢁꢃ<LHOGꢃꢈꢇ;ꢅꢃPSꢃꢆꢌꢄ±ꢆꢌꢈ&ꢉꢃ,5ꢃVSHFꢋ
WUXPꢏꢃ ꢍ& 2ꢎꢃꢀꢂꢇꢒꢃFP ꢉꢃ &ꢃ105ꢃVSHFWUXPꢅꢃ ꢅꢃSSPꢏꢃ
ꢂꢌꢉꢀꢑꢅꢃꢀꢇꢂꢉꢆꢆꢅꢃꢀꢆꢀꢉꢀꢄꢅꢃꢀꢆꢄꢉꢁꢇꢅꢃꢀꢆꢄꢉꢄꢂꢅꢃꢀꢆꢄꢉꢑꢈꢅꢃꢀꢆꢂꢉꢇꢆꢅꢃ
ꢀꢆꢒꢉꢀꢁꢅꢃ ꢀꢌꢈꢉꢄꢈꢅꢃ ꢀꢁꢆꢉꢀꢌꢅꢃꢀꢁꢌꢉꢆꢄꢅꢃ ꢀꢄꢈꢉꢆꢁꢉꢃ )RXQGꢅꢃ ;ꢏꢃꢃ
&ꢃꢈꢆꢉꢀꢂꢊꢃ+ꢃꢌꢉꢈꢄꢊꢃ1ꢃꢀꢇꢉꢁꢆꢉꢃ& + 1 2 ꢉꢃ&DOFXODWHGꢅꢃ;ꢏꢃ
&ꢃꢈꢆꢉꢆꢆꢊꢃ+ꢃꢌꢉꢂꢌꢊꢃ1ꢃꢀꢇꢉꢌꢂꢉꢃ
ꢃꢄꢅ$PLQRSKHQ\OꢆSKHQ\OPHWKDQROVꢀ ,,Dꢀ DQGꢀ ,,Eꢀ
ꢃJHQHUDOꢀ SURFHGXUHꢆꢁꢃ 6RGLXPꢃ WHWUDK\GULGRERUDWHꢅꢃꢃ
ꢆꢉꢑꢄꢃJꢃꢍꢇꢉꢇꢂꢄꢃPROꢎꢅꢃZDVꢃDGGHGꢃRYHUꢃDꢃSHULRGꢃRIꢃꢌꢇꢃPLQꢃ
WRꢃDꢃPL[WXUHꢃRIꢃꢇꢉꢇꢄꢃPROꢃRIꢃꢆꢋDPLQREHQ]RSKHQRQHꢃ,Dꢃ
RUꢃ,EꢃDQGꢃꢆꢄꢇꢃPOꢃRIꢃLVRSURS\OꢃDOFRKROꢅꢃKHDWHGꢃWRꢃꢈꢇ&ꢉꢃ
7KHꢃPL[WXUHꢃZDVꢃVWLUUHGꢃIRUꢃꢌꢃKꢃDWꢃWKDWꢃWHPSHUDWXUHꢃDQGꢃ
SRXUHGꢃRQWRꢃLFHꢅꢃDQGꢃWKHꢃSUHFLSLWDWHꢃZDVꢃILOWHUHGꢃRIIꢃDQGꢃ
UHFU\VWDOOL]HGꢃIURPꢃPHWKDQROꢉꢃꢃ
Eꢉꢃ$ꢃVROXWLRQꢃRIꢃꢄꢉꢌꢃPPROꢃRIꢃFRPSRXQGꢃ,9DꢃRUꢃ,9Eꢃ
DQGꢃꢇꢉꢒꢃJꢃꢍꢀꢄꢉꢒꢃPPROꢎꢃRIꢃSRWDVVLXPꢃK\GUR[LGHꢃLQꢃꢃ
ꢁꢇꢃPOꢃRIꢃDQK\GURXVꢃDOFRKROꢃZDVꢃKHDWHGꢃIRUꢃꢁꢃKꢃXQGHUꢃ
UHIOX[ꢉꢃ7KHꢃ UHVXOWLQJꢃ VXVSHQVLRQꢃ ZDVꢃ HYDSRUDWHGꢃ WRꢃꢃ
DꢃYROXPHꢃRIꢃꢀꢇꢃPOꢃDQGꢃWUHDWHGꢃXQGHUꢃVWLUULQJꢃZLWKꢃꢄꢃPOꢃ
RIꢃꢀꢃ1ꢃK\GURFKORULFꢃDFLGꢃDQGꢃꢄꢇꢃPOꢃRIꢃZDWHUꢉꢃ7KHꢃ
SUHFLSLWDWHꢃZDVꢃILOWHUHGꢃRIIꢅꢃZDVKHGꢃRQꢃDꢃILOWHUꢃZLWKꢃ
ZDWHUꢅꢃDQGꢃUHFU\VWDOOL]HGꢃIURPꢃDOFRKROꢉꢃ<LHOGꢃꢈꢄ;ꢃ
ꢍ,,,Dꢎꢅꢃꢄꢄ;ꢃꢍ,,,Eꢎꢉꢃ
ꢄꢅ$PLQRꢅꢇꢅFKORURSKHQ\OꢃSKHQ\OꢆPHWKDQROꢀ ꢃ,,Dꢆꢁꢃ
<LHOGꢃꢒꢒ;ꢅꢃPSꢃꢀꢀꢆ±ꢀꢀꢌ&ꢊꢃSXEOLVKHGꢃGDWDꢃ>ꢂ@ꢏꢃꢃ
PSꢃꢀꢀꢀ±ꢀꢀꢆ&ꢉꢃ
ꢄꢅ$PLQRꢅꢇꢅQLWURSKHQ\OꢃSKHQ\OꢆPHWKDQROꢀ ꢃ,,Eꢆꢁꢃ
<LHOGꢃꢒꢑ;ꢅꢃPSꢃꢀꢀꢈ±ꢀꢀꢂ&ꢊꢃSXEOLVKHGꢃGDWDꢃ>ꢑ@ꢏꢃꢃ
PSꢃꢀꢀꢈ±ꢀꢀꢂ&ꢎꢉꢃ
1ꢅ>ꢄꢅꢃ ꢅ+\GUR[\EHQ]\OꢆSKHQ\O@WULFKORURDFHWꢅ
DPLGHVꢀ,9DꢀDQGꢀ,9EꢀꢃJHQHUDOꢀSURFHGXUHꢎꢁꢃ$ꢃVROXWLRQꢃ
RIꢃꢀꢉꢑꢃJꢃꢍꢇꢉꢀꢃPROꢎꢃRIꢃWULFKORURDFHW\OFKORULGHꢃLQꢃEHQ]HQHꢃ
ZDVꢃDGGHGꢃGURSZLVHꢃRYHUꢃDꢃSHULRGꢃRIꢃꢌꢇꢃPLQꢃWRꢃDꢃVROXꢋ
WLRQꢃRIꢃꢇꢉꢀꢃPROꢃRIꢃFRPSRXQGꢃ,,DꢃRUꢃ,,EꢃDQGꢃꢀꢃJꢃꢃ
ꢍꢇꢉꢀꢃPROꢎꢃRIꢃWULHWK\ODPLQHꢃLQꢃEHQ]HQHꢅꢃFRROHGꢃWRꢃꢄ&ꢉꢃ
$IWHUꢃꢆꢃKꢅꢃWKHꢃPL[WXUHꢃZDVꢃILOWHUHGꢅꢃWKHꢃILOWUDWHꢃZDVꢃ
HYDSRUDWHGꢃWRꢃ GU\QHVVꢅꢃ DQGꢃ WKHꢃUHVLGXHꢃ ZDVꢃUHFU\VWDOꢋ
OL]HGꢃIURPꢃEHQ]HQHꢉꢃ
ꢌꢅ>ꢃꢄꢅ$PLQRꢅꢇꢅQLWURSKHQ\OꢆꢃSKHQ\OꢆPHWK\O@PRUꢅ
SKROLQHꢀ ꢃ9ꢆꢁꢃ $ꢃ PL[WXUHꢃ RIꢃ ꢀꢃ Jꢃ ꢍꢌꢉꢂꢃ PPROꢎꢃ RIꢃ FRPꢋ
SRXQGꢃ,,,EꢃDQGꢃꢀꢉꢆꢁꢃPOꢃꢍꢀꢁꢉꢆꢃPPROꢎꢃRIꢃPRUSKROLQHꢃLQꢃ
ꢀꢇꢃPOꢃRIꢃGLHWK\OHQHꢃJO\FROꢃZDVꢃVWLUUHGꢃIRUꢃꢈꢃKꢃDWꢃꢆꢀꢇ&ꢉꢃ
7KHꢃ PL[WXUHꢃ ZDVꢃ WKHQꢃ SRXUHGꢃ RQWRꢃ LFHꢃ DQGꢃ H[WUDFWHGꢃ
ZLWKꢃPHWK\OHQHꢃFKORULGHꢉꢃ7KHꢃRUJDQLFꢃSKDVHꢃZDVꢃHYDSꢋ
RUDWHGꢅꢃDQGꢃWKHꢃUHVLGXHꢃZDVꢃUHFU\VWDOOL]HGꢃIURPꢃꢂꢇ;ꢃ
PHWKDQROꢉꢃ<LHOGꢃꢌꢇ;ꢅꢃPSꢃꢀꢑꢀ±ꢀꢑꢆ&ꢉꢃ,5ꢃVSHFWUXPꢏꢃꢃ
ꢍ$U &+1ꢎꢃꢀꢌꢀꢇꢃFP ꢉꢃ &ꢃ105ꢃVSHFWUXPꢅꢃ ꢅꢃSSPꢏꢃ
ꢄꢇꢉꢂꢌꢅꢃ ꢈꢌꢉꢁꢁꢅꢃ ꢈꢂꢉꢈꢌꢅꢃ ꢀꢆꢀꢉꢑꢆꢅꢃ ꢀꢆꢆꢉꢒꢂꢅꢃ ꢀꢆꢁꢉꢀꢑꢅꢃ ꢀꢆꢄꢉꢀꢀꢅꢃ
ꢀꢆꢈꢉꢀꢇꢅꢃꢀꢆꢈꢉꢌꢄꢅꢃꢀꢆꢂꢉꢄꢌꢅꢃꢀꢌꢒꢉꢀꢁꢅꢃꢀꢁꢁꢉꢀꢇꢅꢃꢀꢄꢈꢉꢆꢀꢉꢃ)RXQGꢅꢃ
;ꢏꢃ&ꢃꢈꢄꢉꢀꢑꢊꢃ+ꢃꢈꢉꢇꢒꢊꢃ1ꢃꢀꢌꢉꢌꢂꢉꢃ& + 1 2 ꢉꢃ&DOFXODWHGꢅꢃ
;ꢏꢃ&ꢃꢈꢄꢉꢀꢈꢊꢃ+ꢃꢈꢉꢀꢀꢊꢃ1ꢃꢀꢌꢉꢁꢀꢉꢃ
1ꢅ>ꢇꢅ&KORURꢅꢄꢅꢃ ꢅK\GUR[\EHQ]\OꢆSKHQ\O@WULꢅ
FKORURDFHWDPLGHꢀꢃ,9Dꢆꢁꢃ<LHOGꢃꢑꢇ;ꢅꢃPSꢃꢀꢌꢇ±ꢀꢌꢀ&ꢊꢃ
SXEOLVKHGꢃGDWDꢃ>ꢄ@ꢏꢃPSꢃꢀꢌꢇ±ꢀꢌꢀ&ꢉꢃ
1ꢅ>ꢄꢅꢃ ꢅ+\GUR[\EHQ]\OꢆꢅꢇꢅQLWURSKHQ\O@WULꢅ
FKORURDFHWDPLGHꢀꢃ,9Eꢆꢁꢃ<LHOGꢃꢂꢈ;ꢅꢃPSꢃꢀꢀꢌ±ꢀꢀꢁ&ꢉꢃ
,5ꢃVSHFWUXPꢏꢃ ꢍ& 2ꢎꢃꢀꢂꢇꢄꢃFP ꢉꢃ &ꢃ105ꢃVSHFWUXPꢅꢃ
ꢅꢃSSPꢏꢃꢈꢈꢉꢒꢂꢅꢃꢒꢀꢉꢂꢑꢅꢃꢀꢆꢇꢉꢌꢆꢅꢃꢀꢆꢌꢉꢇꢒꢅꢃꢀꢆꢄꢉꢈꢂꢅꢃꢀꢆꢈꢉꢒꢅꢃ
ꢀꢆꢂꢉꢒꢌꢅꢃꢀꢌꢀꢉꢁꢄꢅꢃꢀꢌꢈꢉꢄꢆꢅꢃꢀꢌꢒꢉꢀꢌꢅꢃꢀꢁꢆꢉꢑꢑꢅꢃꢀꢈꢀꢉꢄꢇꢉꢃ)RXQGꢅꢃ
;ꢏꢃ&ꢃꢁꢈꢉꢀꢄꢊꢃ+ꢃꢆꢉꢂꢑꢊꢃ&Oꢃꢆꢂꢉꢌꢌꢊꢃ1ꢃꢂꢉꢆꢆꢉꢃ& + &O 1 2 ꢉꢃ
&DOFXODWHGꢅꢃ;ꢏꢃ&ꢃꢁꢈꢉꢆꢁꢊꢃ+ꢃꢆꢉꢑꢄꢊꢃ&Oꢃꢆꢂꢉꢌꢇꢊꢃ1ꢃꢂꢉꢀꢒꢉꢃ
7KHꢃ &ꢃ105ꢃVSHFWUDꢃZHUHꢃUHFRUGHGꢃRQꢃDꢃ%UXNHUꢃ
'5;ꢋꢁꢇꢇꢃVSHFWURPHWHUꢃꢍꢁꢇꢇꢃ0+]ꢎꢃIURPꢃVROXWLRQVꢃLQꢃ
&'&O ꢃXVLQJꢃ706ꢃDVꢃLQWHUQDOꢃUHIHUHQFHꢉꢃ7KHꢃ,5ꢃVSHFWUDꢃ
ZHUHꢃ REWDLQHGꢃ LQꢃ .%Uꢃ RQꢃ Dꢃ 6KLPDG]Xꢃ )7,5ꢋꢑꢌꢇꢇꢃ
LQVWUXPHQWꢉꢃ
5()(5(1&(6ꢃ
ꢈꢉꢊꢅ%HQ]R[D]LQHVꢀ,,,DꢀDQGꢀ,,,EꢀꢃJHQHUDOꢀSURFHꢊ
GXUHꢆꢁꢃDꢉꢃ$ꢃPL[WXUHꢃRIꢃꢇꢉꢇꢀꢆꢃPROꢃRIꢃFRPSRXQGꢃ,,DꢃRUꢃ
,,EꢃDQGꢃꢆꢉꢈꢃPOꢃꢍꢇꢉꢇꢆꢁꢃPROꢎꢃRIꢃ1ꢋPHWK\OPRUSKROLQHꢃLQꢃ
ꢈꢇꢃ POꢃ RIꢃ ꢀꢅꢁꢋGLR[DQHꢃ ZDVꢃ KHDWHGꢃ WRꢃ ꢄꢇ&ꢃ DQGꢃ ZDVꢃ
WUHDWHGꢃZLWKꢃSKRVJHQHꢃRYHUꢃDꢃSHULRGꢃRIꢃꢄꢃKꢉꢃ7KHꢃSUHFLSꢋ
LWDWHꢃ ZDVꢃILOWHUHGꢃRIIꢃDQGꢃ ZDVKHGꢃRQꢃDꢃILOWHUꢃ ZLWKꢃꢃ
ꢀꢅꢁꢋGLR[DQHꢅꢃWKHꢃILOWUDWHꢃZDVꢃHYDSRUDWHGꢃWRꢃGU\QHVVꢅꢃWKHꢃ
UHVLGXHꢃZDVꢃGLVVROYHGꢃLQꢃPHWK\OHQHꢃFKORULGHꢅꢃDQGꢃWKHꢃ
VROXWLRQꢃZDVꢃZDVKHGꢃZLWKꢃZDWHUꢉꢃ7KHꢃVROYHQWꢃZDVꢃ
GLVWLOOHGꢃRIIꢅꢃDQGꢃWKHꢃUHVLGXHꢃZDVꢃUHFU\VWDOOL]HGꢃIURPꢃ
EHQ]HQHꢉꢃ
ꢀꢉꢃ0DVKNRYVNLLꢅꢃ0ꢉ'ꢉꢅꢃ/HNDUVWYHQQ\HꢀVUHGVWYDꢃꢍ'UXJVꢎꢅꢃ
0RVFRZꢏꢃ1RYD\Dꢃ9ROQDꢅꢃꢆꢇꢇꢄꢅꢃSꢉꢃꢀꢆꢇꢇꢉꢃ
ꢆꢉꢃ%RJDWVNLLꢅꢃ$ꢉ9ꢉꢅꢃ$QGURQDWLꢅꢃ6ꢉ$ꢉꢅꢃDQGꢃ*RORYHQNRꢅꢃ1ꢉ<Dꢉꢅꢃ
ꢃ
ꢃ
ꢀ
ꢃ
7UDQNYLOL]DWRU\ꢀ ꢌꢍꢁꢎꢊEHQ]GLD]HSLQ\ꢀ Lꢀ URGVWYHQQ\Hꢀ VWUXNꢊ
WXU\ꢏꢃ >7UDQTXLOL]HUVꢃ ꢍꢀꢅꢁꢋ%HQ]RGLD]HSLQHVꢃ DQGꢃ 5HODWHGꢃ
6WUXFWXUHVꢎ@ꢅꢃ.LHYꢏꢃ1DXNRYDꢃ'XPNDꢅꢃꢀꢒꢑꢇꢅꢃSꢉꢃꢆꢑꢇꢉꢃ
ꢌꢉꢃ%HOOꢅꢃ 6ꢉ&ꢉꢅꢃ 6XONRZVNLꢅꢃ 7ꢉ(ꢉꢅꢃ *RFKPDQꢅꢃ &ꢉꢅꢃ DQGꢃ &KLOGꢋꢃ
UHVVꢅꢃ6ꢉ-ꢉꢅꢃ-ꢂꢀ2UJꢂꢀ&KHPꢉꢅꢃꢀꢒꢈꢆꢅꢃYROꢉꢃꢆꢂꢅꢃSꢉꢃꢄꢈꢆꢉꢃ
ꢁꢉꢃ%HOOꢅꢃ 6ꢉ&ꢉꢃ DQGꢃ &KLOGUHVVꢅꢃ 6ꢉ-ꢉꢅꢃ -ꢂꢀ 2UJꢂꢀ &KHPꢉꢅꢃ ꢀꢒꢈꢆꢅꢃꢃ
YROꢉꢃꢆꢂꢅꢃSꢉꢃꢀꢈꢒꢀꢉꢃ
ꢃ
ꢃ
5866,$1ꢃꢃ-2851$/ꢃꢃ2)ꢃꢃ25*$1,&ꢃꢃ&+(0,675<ꢃꢃꢃ9ROꢉꢃꢃꢁꢆꢃꢃꢃ1Rꢉꢃꢃꢒꢃꢃꢃꢆꢇꢇꢈꢃ