S. Majumdar, K. B. Sloan / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 16 (2006) 3590–3594
3593
Table 2. Water solubility (SAQ), solubility in IPM (SIPM), log partition coefficients between IPM and pH 4.0 buffer and flux from IPM through
hairless mice skins (JMIPM) of NANAOCAM prodrugs and parent drugs
Compound
SAQ (mM)
SIPM (mM)
logKIPM:4.0
JMIPM (lmole cm2 hꢀ1
)
% of parent drug obtained after diffusion
APAP
1
Th
100
1.91
14.13
0.34
2.69
0.02
1.35
ꢀ1.72
ꢀ0.45
ꢀ0.51
ꢀ0.04
ꢀ1.75
0.03
0.51
1.11
—
23
—
63
—
100
45.71
46
0.48
0.16
9
9.33
1.12
1.45
6MP
813
0.0038
0.015
NANAOCAM-carboxylic acid conjugates are chemical-
ly too unstable to serve as useful derivatives (compared
to phenols which are chemically stable) because the leav-
ing group has a pKa of ꢁ3–5 (compared to 6.8–9.5), e.g.,
10, t1/2 ꢁ 6 min at pH 7.4 and 37 ꢁC. The NArNAO-
CAM promoiety enhances the chemical stability of
phenolic derivatives compared to NANAOCAM pro-
moiety, and by analogy they should increase the stability
of carboxylic acid conjugates too. Thus, the implication
of mechanism of hydrolysis of NANAOCAM-Y conju-
gates in prodrug design is the design of a more stable
NArNAOCAM analogue of carboxylic acids which
can be conveniently formulated but would hydrolyze
independent of enzymes and be clinically useful. We
are currently investigating the application of NArNAO-
CAM prodrug technology to carboxylic acids like
naproxen.
O–CH2 of ROCOOCH2 with a substituted nitrogen
(N–R; R = alkyl) makes it possible to increase solubility
in a membrane and increases permeability across a
biological barrier such as skin.
In conclusion, NANAOCAM and NArNAOCAM pro-
moieties can act as soft alkyl derivatives of polar drugs.
The mechanism of chemical hydrolysis is believed to be
SN1 with phenol, Th or 6MP acting as the nucleofuge.
Proof-of-mechanism being SN1 comes from the in-
creased stability of NArNAOCAM derivatives com-
pared to that of NANAOCAM prodrugs. These
NArNAOCAM derivatives can potentially be useful in
designing stable carboxylic acid prodrugs whose phar-
maceutical formulation should be easier than that of
their NANAOCAM counterparts. The delivery of phe-
nol and thiol containing drugs like APAP and 6MP
can be enhanced by utilizing the NANAOCAM promo-
iety. The flux of APAP was increased by 2- and 4-fold
for 6MP from IPM across hairless mouse skin. Synthesis
of homologous series of NANAOCAM prodrugs of
APAP, Th and 6MP in order to optimize flux across
the skin is currently under progress. A more water-solu-
ble NANAOCAM derivative should further enhance
permeation of APAP and 6MP and also increase the
permeation of Th across the skin.
Although NANAOCAM-phenols hydrolyse by an SN1-
type of pathway, they are chemically too stable to revert
to the parent drug at a sufficient rate to be effective pro-
drugs based on chemical hydrolysis. To evaluate if these
derivatives hydrolyse on their passage through the skin
and increase permeation, selected prodrugs 1, 8 and 9
were analyzed in in vitro skin permeation studies (Table
2). The physicochemical characterization of these select-
ed NANAOCAM derivatives10 and the parent drugs
was also carried out (Table 2). In vitro skin permeation
studies through hairless mouse skin were carried out
using suspensions in IPM.10 The steady-state flux was
calculated from the slope of cumulative amounts of drug
permeated versus time. The in vitro diffusion cell exper-
iments from IPM through hairless mouse skin show
reversion of NANAOCAM prodrugs to the parent
drug. The permeation of 1 and 8 was enhanced com-
pared to the parent drug, while the permeation of 9
was lower than that of Th.11
Supplementary data
Supplementary data associated with this article can be
References and notes
1. (a) Bundgard, H. Design and Application of Prodrugs. In
A Textbook of Drug Design and Development; Krogsgaard-
Larsen, P., Bundgard, H., Eds.; Harwood: Reading, UK,
1991; pp 113–191; (b) Sloan, K. B.; Wasdo, S. Med. Res.
Rev. 2003, 23, 763; (c) Rautio, J.; Nevalainen, T.; Taipale,
H.; Vepsalainen, J.; Gynther, J.; Pederson, T.; Jarvinen, T.
J. J. Med. Chem. 2000, 43, 1489.
2. Siver, K. G.; Sloan, K. B. J. Pharm. Sci. 1990, 79, 66.
3. (a) Moreira, R.; Calheiros, T.; Cabrita, J.; Mendes, E.;
Pimentel, M.; Iley, J. Pharm. Res. 1996, 13, 70; (b) Iley, J.;
Moreira, R.; Calheiros, T.; Mendes, E. Pharm. Res. 1997,
14, 1634; (c) Moreira, R.; Mendes, E.; Calheiros, T.;
Bacelo, M. J.; Iley, J. Tetrahedron Lett. 1994, 35, 7107.
4. General procedure for alkylation reactions: the alkylation
of phenols with NANAOCAM-Cl and NArNAOCAM-Cl
was carried out by refluxing equimolar equivalents of
The increase in permeation of prodrugs 1 and 8 can be
attributed to the increase in biphasic solubility of the
prodrugs compared to the parent,1b,c,12 while lower per-
meation of 9 was because of the large decrease in water
solubility which could not be compensated by the in-
crease in lipid solubility of the prodrug compared to
Th. Thus, NANAOCAM derivatives of phenols, imides
and thiols represent a novel class of prodrugs which are
sufficiently chemically stable to allow formulation but
sufficiently enzymatically labile to revert to the parent
drug at a useful rate. Shorter chain NANAOCAM, pro-
drugs of phenols, have both higher lipid and water sol-
ubilities compared to ACOM and AOCOM phenolic
conjugates.11 Thus, replacing the oxygen atom in