Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 6 of 8
Y)*[OGY\-G$5[
:
4"="5$<= =- FG-J1B& " !#1_!& <=G"=&'$ =- <1'#1714"#=5$
))>
S!#<"5!<( `> ;>m 6-FF"X"( ꢀ>m 9"GX( ,> R>m \1<4/-7( ,> 3>m
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
6
5-@&G =/& "4=1J"=1-# C"GG1&G -7 8&=/"#& C-G$5"=1-#> H/1< 3Z%V
C"<&B '&#&G"5 <=G"=&'$ /-5B< FG-81<& 1# "BBG&<<1#' 4/"55&#'1#'
R"</1'!4/1( \> S>m 9&G1"#"( a> ꢀ>( R-8-'&#&-!< %!#4=1-#"51T"=1-#
-7 3&=/"#&> ;,!<( -!%( 3?*@> 33A Y):[( bM2)VbMN:>
4
"="5$=14 G&"4=1-#< 1#J-5J1#' /1'/5$ 1#&G= <!C<=G"=&<>
)2>
,4/@"GT( R>( ?/&81<=G$ @1=/ 3&=/"#&c ?-#4&F=< a"=/&G
=
/"# a&41F&<> ꢀ7E!F( ;,!<( G7"( 10( 3?**> >4 YU:[( )QQKPV)Q))M>
ꢀ
,,Z?OꢀHLE ?Z`HL`H
!FF-G=1#' O#7-G8"=1-#
H/1< 8"=&G1"5 1< "J"15"C5& 7G&& -7 4/"G'& J1" =/& O#=&G#&= "=
):>
?--X( ꢀ> 6>m ,4/185&G( ,> E>m 3"=T'&G( ꢀ> ;>m ,"#7-GB( 3>
,
>( ?"="5$<=V4-#=G-55&B <&5&4=1J1=$ 1# =/& ?tR C-G$5"=1-# -7 8&=/"#&
#B &=/"#&> .6/!76! 3?*<> 8>3 YP2bQ[( )U2)V)U2U>
)U> ,81=/( 6> H>m \&GG1==( ,>m S-#Tr5&TV3-G&1G"<( 3>m ꢀ/#( ,>m
,
"
/
ꢀ
4
==FcddF!C<>"4<>-G'>m ,$#=/&<1< "#B 4/"G"4=&G1T"=1-# -7 &'()*( &'(
)2( &'()*(+'( "#B &'(ꢀ)2(+'m G&"4=1-# FG-4&B!G&< "#B
/"G"4=&G1T"=1-# G&<!5= -7 8&=/"#& C-G$5"=1-#m E%H 4"54!5"=1-#<>
,81=/( 3> a>m \"1X( 3>VR>m 31#B1-5"( E> ;>( ?"="5$=14 C-G$5"=1-# -7
8&=/"#&> .6/!76! 3?*<> 8>3 YP2bQ[( )U2UV)U2N>
)M>
-@VH&8F&G"=!G& `-#-W1B"=1J& ꢀ4=1J"=1-# -7 3&=/"#& -J&G
u&8vRud&8vVS"55-"5!81#-<1514"=& Y3%O[ .&-51=&> .6/!76! *==@>
A> YM:QU[( )2bPV)2bb>
)P> %!k18-=-( 6>V1>m a1C&1G-( %> R>m ꢀJ"5-<V\-Gk"( 3>m O'5&<1"(
?/-!B/"G$( ^> a>m 61#"'&( ꢀ> 6>m ?/-!B/"G$( H> ^>(
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
0
9
ꢀ
IHRZa O`%Za3ꢀHOZ`
*ꢁ
> %&#'( +> ,-#'( "#B .> 01 4-#=G1C!=&B &_!"55$ =- =/1< @-GX>
-GG&<F-#B1#' ꢀ!=/-G L8"15c @&#C1#51#n!4/14"'->&B!
L>( ,=G!4=!G& "#B a&"4=1J1=$ -7 9BZWd.GZ2?"="5$<=< 7-G 3&=/"#&
ZW1B"=1-# "= 0-@ H&8F&G"=!G&<> '( ;#"#$( *==A> 3AH Y2[( U:)VUU2>
?
)
,
N>
4/w=/( %>( ,-51B ?"="5$<=< 7-G =/& ,&5&4=1J& 0-@VH&8F&G"=!G&
ZW1B"=1-# -7 3&=/"#& =- 3&=/"#-5> ꢀ7E!F( ;,!<( G7"( 10( 3??=>
: Y:N[( PKQKVPK)2>
)b> H"#'( 9>m ./!( x>m A!( .>m 3"( E>( 3&=/"#& "4=1J"=1-#c
=/& F"<= "#B 7!=!G&> 17!2E@ 17%/2*7( .6/( 3?*:> A Yb[( 2MbQV2MK)>
)K> .!-( .>m a"8qG&T( 9> ;>m ,&#"#"$"X&( ,> E>m 01!( 9>m
a-BG1'!&T( ;> ꢀ>( 0-@VH&8F&G"=!G& ?-#J&G<1-# -7 3&=/"#& =-
&=/"#-5 -# ?&ZWd?!2Z ?"="5$<=<c A"=&G ?-#=G-55&B ꢀ4=1J"=1-#
7 =/& ?tR \-#B> '( ꢀ<( ;,!<( .*6( 3?*<> 38: YU2[( ):b)QV):b):>
Q> 01"#'( .>m 01( H>m 618( 3>m ꢀ<=/"'1G1( ꢀ>m A&"J&G( ;> %>(
-@V=&8F&G"=!G& "4=1J"=1-# -7 8&=/"#& -# =/&
OGZu<!Cv2ud<!CvY))Q[ <!G7"4&> .6/!76! 3?*@> 8>D YP::M[( 2KKV
9"5X-J1=<( a>m ꢀ#=-#1&==1( 3>m 6!/#( 9>m H/-8"<( ꢀ>m
Za?OE
5
ꢀ?6`ZA0LES3L`H
H/1< @-GX @"< <!FF-G=&B C$ `,% Y?RLV)UPUKU)[> A& =/"#X 3G
A&#C- R"# "#B 3G H"-X!# 0!- 7-G &WF&G18&#="5 /&5F> ꢁꢀ,
3
-
2
"
3
=
-
#"5$<1< @"< F&G7-G8&B "= \&"851#& )QV\3( <!FF-G=&B C$ =/&
"=&G1"5< a&<&"G4/ ?-55"C-G"=1J& ꢀ44&<< H&"8 Y3a?ꢀH[> I<& -7
/& ꢀBJ"#4&B 9/-=-# ,-!G4&( "# Z7714& -7 ,41& I<&G %"4151=$
F&G"=&B 7-G =/& I>,> EZL Z7714& -7 ,41& C$ ꢀ`0( @"<
!FF-G=&B C$ =/& I>,> EZL !#B&G ?-#=G"4= `-> ELVꢀ?Q2V
0
:
2
Q:>
)>
<
OX!#-( H>m ./&#'( ;>m ^k!#-J( ꢀ>m ,"#4/&TV,"#4/&T( 3>m
QP?R)):MN> .> 01 "#B +> 91 "4X#-@5&B'& 71#"#41"5 <!FF-G= 7G-8
=/& ?/1#" ,4/-5"G</1F ?-!#415>
ZG=!y-( 3> ꢀ>m 9"/5<( E> a>m %!5=-#( ;> 0>m ?"8"1-#1( E> 3>m 01( .>m
a"$( E>m 3&/B1( \> 0>m \G-@#1#'( `> E>m %"G/"( Z> 6>m R!FF( ;> H>m
?
3
G"8&G( ?> ;>m S"'51"GB1( 0>m 0&G4/&G( ;> ꢀ>( 3&=/"#& ZW1B"=1-# =-
&=/"#-5 ?"="5$T&B C$ ?!VZW- ?5!<=&G< ,="C151T&B 1# `IV)QQQ
a&7&G&<
3&="5tZG'"#14 %G"8&@-GX> '( ꢀ<( ;,!<( .*6( 3?*@> 38H Y:Q[(
)Q2KUV)Q:Q)>
)
>
?5&##&55( 3> \>m R-J5"#B( 3>m \--=/( ;> ,>m R&#G$( 9>m
A1#=&G<( A> ;>( %-G8"=1-# -7 #"=!G"5 '"< /$BG"=&< 1# 8"G1#&
&B18&#=<c )> ?-#4&F=!"5 8-B&5 -7 '"< /$BG"=& 'G-@=/ 4-#B1=1-#&B
2
2>
\"&X( ;>m a!#'="@&&J-G"#1=( \>m 9&1( ꢁ>m 9"GX( 3>m %"XG"(
,> ?>m 01!( +>V,>m 3"=/&!( a>m ꢀ5</818G1( ,> ꢀ>m ꢀ5</&/G1( ,>m
<
HG14X&==( ?> ꢀ>m ,-8-Gk"1( S> ꢀ>m +"'/1( Z> 3>( \1-1#<F1G&B 3&="5t
ZG'"#14 %G"8&@-GX ?"="5$<=< 7-G ,&5&4=1J& 3&=/"#& ZW1B"=1-# =-
C$ /-<= <&B18&#= FG-F&G=1&<> '( )!*+,&( -!&( .*$/0 1#2", *===> 345
Y\)Q[( 22KbMV2:QQ:>
3
&=/"#-5> '( ꢀ<( ;,!<( .*6( 3?*A> 354 YM)[( )b2QbV)b2)P>
2:> ?!1( ꢁ>m 01( R>m A"#'( +>m R!( +>m R!"( 0>m 01( R>m R"#(
ꢁ>m 01!( x>m +"#'( %>m R&( 0>m ?/&#( ꢁ>m 01( x>m ꢁ1"-( ;>m E&#'( E>m
2
,
:
<
>
6&GG( a> ꢀ>( `"=!G"5 S"< %G-8 ,/"5& \!G<=< Z#=- =/&
4&#&> .6/!76! 3?*?> 89: YMKbP[( )P2UV)P2P>
?"C"55&G-( ꢀ>m 9oG&T( 9> ;>( 3&=/"#& "< G"@ 8"=&G1"5 1#
$#=/&=14 4/&81<=G$c =/& 71#"5 7G-#=1&G> ;,!<( .*6( -!%( 3?*6> 59
Y2:[( bbQKVbb2Q>
>
\
?
"-( ꢁ>( a--8VH&8F&G"=!G& 3&=/"#& ?-#J&G<1-# C$ SG"F/&#&V
-#71#&B ,1#'5& OG-# ꢀ=-8<> ;,!< 3?*A> 5 Yb[( )KQ2V)K)Q>
2
U>
E> ;>m \"1X( 3>VR>( a"=1-#"5 E&<1'# -7 " ?"="5$<= 7-G =/& ,&5&4=1J&
-#-C-G$5"=1-# -7 3&=/"#&> ꢀ;. ;#"#$( 3?*A> : Y))[( )QQ2)V
QQ:)>
2M>
Ze6&&77&( 3>m A!( ?>VE>( 9-G-!< 3&="55-F-GF/$G1#14 %G"8&@-GX<
-#<=G!4=&B 7G-8 3&="5 M()Q()M(2QVH&=G"X1<Y:(MV
C1<4"GC-W$5F/&#$5[F-GF/$G1# 7-G R1'/5$ L77141&#= "#B ,&5&4=1J&
"="5$=14 ZW1B"=1-# -7 ꢀ5X$5C&#T&#&<> '( ꢀ<( ;,!<( .*6( 3?*3>
85 Y2M[( )QP:bV)QPUM>
P> +"#'( ꢁ>V0>m .-!( ?>m R&( +>m ./"-( 3>m ?/&#( \>m ꢁ1"#'(
ꢀ/#( ,>m ,-G<4/&( E>m \&GG1==( ,>m S"!( 3> a>m 31#B1-5"(
U>
R-G#( a>m ,4/5p'5( a>( 3&=/"#& ꢀ4=1J"=1-# C$
R&=&G-'&#&-!< ?"="5$<1<> ;#"#$( =!""( 3?*;> 35> Y)[( 2:V:K>
3
)
M>
L>( R-8-'&#&-!< <$#'"< 4-#J&G<1-#> ;**20( ;,!<( -!%( 3?**>
>> YN[( bb)VbKb>
A&<=( `> 3>m 3155&G( ꢀ> ;> 3>m 0"C1#'&G( ;> ꢀ>m \&G4"@( ;>
+"#'( ꢁ>V0>m ꢁ1&( 3>VR>m .-!( ?>m R&( +>m ?/&#( \>m
9
P>
`
ꢀ5J"G&TVS"5J"#( 3> ?>m 3-="( `>m Zk&B"( 3>m a-k"<( ,>m
"J"GG-( a> 3>m %1&GG-( ;> 0> S>( E1G&4= 8&=/"#& 4-#J&G<1-# G-!=&<
?
=
- 4/&814"5< "#B 7!&5<> ;#"#$( ?*0#@ 3?**> 3A3 Y)[( )MV2:>
N> A"#'( \>m ꢀ5C"GG"4q#V,!"T-( ,>m 9"'r#VH-GG&<( +>m
`1X-55"( L>( ꢀBJ"#4&< 1# 8&=/"#& 4-#J&G<1-# FG-4&<<&<> ;#"#$(
*0#@ 3?*@> 9:>( )UNV)Mb>
?
3
2
?
,>m Zf6&&77&( 3>m A!( ?>VE>( ꢀ ,="C5& 314G-F-G-!< 31W&BV3&="5
3&="5tZG'"#14 %G"8&@-GX @1=/ R1'/5$ ꢀ4=1J& ?!2z ,1=&< 7-G
L77141&#= ?G-<<VE&/$BG-'&#"=1J& ?-!F51#' a&"4=1-#<> ;,!<( 1I2(
b>
?G"C=G&&( a> R>( H/& -G'"#-8&="5514 4/&81<=G$ -7 "5X"#&<>
;
,!<( -!%( *=A;> :> YU[( 2UMV2PK>
K>
\&GX-@1=T( ;>m SG&&#&( ;> 9>m ?/-( R>m a!<41s( \>( H/&
'
2
( 3?*:> 94 YM[( )UUNV)UM2>
N> ꢁ1"-( E> ;>m ZX="@1&4( ;>m 315#&G( 9> ;>m 0-#'( ;> a>( 9-G&
1
-#1T"=1-# F-=&#=1"5< -7 ?RU "#B ?EU> '( ;,!<( B,@&C *=A@> :D Y2[(
PNUVPNP>
)Q>
L#J1G-#8&#= L77&4=< -# ?"="5$=14 ?$45-/&W"#& ZW1B"=1-# 1#
LWF"#B&B %&2YB-CB4[ ꢀ#"5-'!&<> '( ꢀ<( ;,!<( .*6( 3?*<> 38:
YU:[( )U:N)V)U:NK>
\5"#X<C$( ,> ;>m L551<-#( S> \>( \-#B E1<<-41"=1-#
L#&G'1&< -7 ZG'"#14 3-5&4!5&<> ꢀ66( ;,!<( -!&( 3??6> 8D YU[( 2MMV
P:>
2
2b>
;1( 9>m 3"##"( 6>m 01#( .>m %&#'( ꢁ>m IGC"#( ꢀ>m ,-#'( +>m
X
ACS Paragon Plus Environment