6<17+(6,6ꢊꢊ2)ꢊꢊ)86('ꢊꢊ48,12/,=,1(ꢊꢊ'(5,9$7,9(6ꢊꢊ
ꢀꢆꢁꢂꢊ
QLWURJHQꢃFRQWDLQLQJꢊ KHWHURF\FOHVꢊ KDYLQJꢊ Dꢊ EULGJHKHDGꢊ UHYHDOHGꢊGLUHFWꢊ DQGꢊ UHYHUVHꢊFRXSOLQJꢊ EHWZHHQꢊꢀꢀꢃ+ꢊꢊ
ꢎ ꢊꢂꢌꢉꢄꢊSSPꢏꢊDQGꢊꢀꢃ&+ ꢊꢎ ꢊꢅꢌꢍꢉꢊSSPꢏꢊDQGꢊEHWZHHQꢊꢊ
ꢉꢃ+ꢊ ꢎ ꢊ ꢍꢌꢑꢀꢊ SSPꢏꢊ DQGꢊ ꢄꢃ&+ ꢊꢎ ꢊꢅꢌꢄꢁꢊSSPꢏꢌꢊ &RXSOLQJꢊ
EHWZHHQꢊSURWRQVꢊLQꢊWKHꢊPHWK\OꢊJURXSꢊꢎ ꢊꢅꢌꢍꢉꢊSSPꢏꢊDQGꢊ
PHWK\OHQHꢊXQLWꢊꢎ ꢊꢄꢌꢀꢀꢊSSPꢏꢊRIꢊWKHꢊEHQ]\OꢊVXEVWLWXHQWꢊ
ꢎZKLFKꢊVKRXOGꢊRFFXUꢊLQꢊVWUXFWXUHꢊ,9ꢏꢊZDVꢊQRWꢊGHWHFWHGꢌꢊ
7KXVꢊ WKHꢊ DERYHꢊ VSHFWUDOꢊ GDWDꢊ XQDPELJXRXVO\ꢊ LQGLFDWHꢊ
IRUPDWLRQꢊ RIꢊ GHULYDWLYHVꢊ ,,,ꢊ ZLWKꢊ WKHꢊ FDUERQ\Oꢊ JURXSꢊꢊ
LQꢊ WKHꢊ ꢃSRVLWLRQꢊ RIꢊ WKHꢊ S\ ULGLQHꢊ ULQJꢊ UDWKHUꢊ WKDQꢊꢊ
ꢃS\ULGLQRQHꢊGHULYDWLYHVꢊ,9ꢌꢊ
QLWURJHQꢊDWRPꢌꢊ
%\ꢊUHDFWLRQꢊRIꢊ6FKLIIꢊEDVHVꢊ,D±,GꢊZLWKꢊ ꢃNHWRꢊHVWHUVꢊ
,,D±,,GꢊRQꢊKHDWLQJꢊLQꢊDQꢊLQHUWꢊDWPRVSKHUHꢊꢎDUJRQꢋꢊQLWꢃ
URJHQꢏꢊ ZHꢊ REWDLQHGꢊ S\ULGR>ꢅꢋꢀꢃD@LVRTXLQROLQHꢊ GHULYDꢃ
WLYHVꢊ,,,D±,,,Gꢊꢎ6FKHPHꢊꢀꢏꢌꢊ7KHꢊVWUXFWXUHꢊRIꢊWKHꢊSURGꢃ
XFWVꢊZDVꢊFRQVLVWHQWꢊZLWKꢊWKHLUꢊVSHFWUDOꢊSDUDPHWHUVꢌꢊ1Rꢊ
DOWHUQDWLYHꢊꢅꢃR[RS\ULGLQHꢊGHULYDWLYHVꢊ,9ꢊZHUHꢊGHWHFWHGꢊ
LQꢊ WKHꢊ UHDFWLRQꢊ PL[WXUHVꢋꢊ LQGLFDWLQJꢊ KLJKꢊ UHJLRVHOHFꢃ
WLYLW\ꢊRIꢊWKHVHꢊUHDFWLRQVꢌꢊ7KHꢊUHDFWLRQVꢊLQꢊKLJKꢃERLOLQJꢊ
ꢎESꢊ!ꢀꢁꢁ&ꢏꢊRUJDQLFꢊVROYHQWVꢊVXFKꢊDVꢊWROXHQHꢊRUꢊ[\OHQHꢊ
UHTXLUHꢊDꢊORQJHUꢊWLPHꢋꢊEXWꢊWKHꢊ\LHOGꢊDQGꢊSXULW\ꢊRIꢊWKHꢊ
SURGXFWVꢊFKDQJHꢊLQVLJQLILFDQWO\ꢌꢊ
3\ULGR>ꢅꢋꢀꢃD@LVRTXLQROLQHVꢊ,,,D±,,,GꢊDUHꢊFU\VWDOOLQHꢊ
VXEVWDQFHVꢊZKLFKꢊPHOWꢊDWꢊDꢊKLJKꢊWHPSHUDWXUHꢋꢊDVꢊDꢊUXOHꢊ
ZLKWRXWꢊGHFRPSRVLWLRQꢌꢊ7KH\ꢊDUHꢊPRGHUDWHO\ꢊVROXEOHꢊꢊ
LQꢊKDORJHQDWHGꢊK\GURFDUERQVꢊDQGꢊDOFRKROVꢊDQGꢊSRRUO\ꢊ
VROXEOHꢊLQꢊHWKHUVꢋꢊHVWHUVꢋꢊWHWUDK\GURIXUDQꢋꢊGLR[DQHꢋꢊDQGꢊ
ZDWHUꢌꢊ&RPSRXQGVꢊ,,,D±,,,GꢊFU\VWDOOL]HGꢊIURPꢊZDWHUꢃ
FRQWDLQLQJꢊVROYHQWVꢊPDLQO\ꢊDVꢊFU\VWDOꢊK\GUDWHVꢌꢊ7KHꢊ
\LHOGVꢊRIꢊFRPSRXQGVꢊ,,,D±,,,GꢊLVRODWHGꢊDVꢊDQDO\WLFDOO\ꢊ
SXUHꢊVXEVWDQFHVꢊZHUHꢊꢉꢂ±ꢑꢍOꢐꢊWKHUHIRUHꢋꢊWKHꢊGHVFULEHGꢊ
7KHꢊ VWUXFWXUHꢊ RIꢊ FRPSRXQGVꢊ ,,,D±,,,Gꢊ ZDVꢊ FRQꢃ
ILUPHGꢊE\ꢊWKHꢊVSHFWUDOꢊGDWDꢌꢊ7KHLUꢊ,5ꢊVSHFWUDꢊFRQWDLQHGꢊ
VWURQJꢊDEVRUSWLRQꢊEDQGVꢊDWꢊꢀꢈꢆꢈ±ꢀꢈꢆꢁꢊFP ꢊZKLFKꢋꢊLQꢊ
NHHSLQJꢊZLWKꢊWKHꢊGDWDꢊRIꢊ>ꢀꢄ±ꢀꢉ@ꢋꢊVKRXOGꢊEHꢊDVVLJQHGꢊWRꢊ
VWUHWFKLQJꢊYLEUDWLRQVꢊRIꢊWKHꢊFDUERQ\OꢊJURXSꢊLQꢊWKHꢊ
S\ULGLQHꢊULQJꢌꢊ0HGLXPꢃLQWHQVLW\ꢊDQGꢊZHDNꢊEDQGVꢊLQꢊꢊ
WKHꢊUHJLRQꢊꢀꢉꢍꢁ±ꢀꢈꢑꢁꢊFP ꢊFRUUHVSRQGꢊWRꢊYLEUDWLRQVꢊRIꢊ UHDFWLRQꢊPD\ꢊEHꢊUHFRPPHQGHGꢊDVꢊSUHSDUDWLYHꢊURXWHꢊWRꢊ
& &ꢊERQGVꢊLQꢊWKHꢊS\ULGLQHꢊULQJꢊ>ꢀꢄ@ꢋꢊDQGꢊVWURQJꢊEDQGVꢊ
DWꢊꢀꢈꢉꢈ±ꢀꢈꢅꢁꢊDQGꢊꢀꢈꢀꢅ±ꢀꢄꢆꢁꢊFP ꢊRULJLQDWHꢊIURPꢊ
YLEUDWLRQVꢊRIꢊDURPDWLFꢊFDUERQ±FDUERQꢊERQGVꢊ>ꢀꢂ@ꢌꢊ
IXVHGꢊD]LQHVꢊKDYLQJꢊDꢊEULGJHKHDGꢊQLWURJHQꢊDWRPꢌꢊ
(;3(5,0(17$/ꢊ
7KHꢊ89ꢊVSHFWUDꢊRIꢊ ,,,D±,,,GꢊDUHꢊFKDUDFWHUL]HGꢊE\ꢊ
WKHꢊSUHVHQFHꢊRIꢊWZRꢊDEVRUSWLRQꢊEDQGVꢊDWꢊꢅꢈꢂ±ꢅꢉꢑꢊDQGꢊ
ꢅꢆꢀ±ꢍꢁꢆꢊQPꢋꢊZKLFKꢊLVꢊFRQVLVWHQWꢊZLWKꢊSXEOLVKHGꢊGDWDꢊ
>ꢀꢆ@ꢌꢊ,QꢊDGGLWLRQꢋꢊFRPSRXQGVꢊ,,,FꢊDQGꢊ,,,GꢊGLVSOD\HGꢊ
PHGLXPꢃLQWHQVLW\ꢊ EDQGVꢊ DWꢊ ꢊ ꢅꢄꢁꢊ QPꢊ GXHꢊ WRꢊ HOHFWURQꢊ
WUDQVLWLRQVꢊ LQꢊ WKHꢊ PHWKR[\ꢃVXEVWLWXWHGꢊ EHQ]HQHꢊ ULQJVꢌꢊ
,QꢊWKHꢊPDVVꢊVSHFWUDꢊRIꢊDOOꢊFRPSRXQGVꢊ,,,ꢋꢊZHꢊREVHUYHGꢊ
SHDNVꢊIURPꢊWKHꢊFRUUHVSRQGLQJꢊPROHFXODUꢊLRQVꢋꢊ>0ꢀꢓꢊꢀ@ ꢊ
DQGꢊ>0ꢀ±ꢊꢀ@ ꢋꢊDQGꢊIUDJPHQWꢊLRQVꢌꢊ
7KHꢊ SURJUHVVꢊ RIꢊ UHDFWLRQVꢊ DQGꢊ WKHꢊ SXULW\ꢊ RIꢊ FRPꢃ
SRXQGVꢊ,,,D±,,,GꢊZHUHꢊPRQLWRUHGꢊE\ꢊ7/&ꢊRQꢊ6LOXIROꢊ
89ꢃꢅꢈꢄꢊSODWHVꢊXVLQJꢊFKORURIRUP±PHWKDQROꢊꢎꢆꢌꢈꢔꢀꢌꢈꢏꢊDVꢊ
HOXHQWꢊDQGꢊE\ꢊJDVꢊFKURPDWRJUDSK\ꢃ±PDVVꢊVSHFWURPHWU\ꢊ
RQꢊDQꢊ+3ꢊꢈꢆꢑꢁꢇꢈꢑꢂꢅꢊ*&±06ꢊV\VWHPꢊꢎ+3ꢃꢈ06ꢊTXDUW]ꢊ
FDSLOODU\ꢊ FROXPQꢋꢊ ꢍꢁꢊ Pîꢁꢌꢅꢈꢊ PPîꢁꢌꢅꢈꢊ Pꢐꢊ FDUULHUꢊ
JDVꢊKHOLXPꢋꢊIORZꢊUDWHꢊꢁꢌꢂ±ꢀꢊPOꢇPLQꢐꢊLQMHFWRUꢊWHPSHUDꢃ
WXUHꢊꢅꢈꢁ&ꢐꢊRYHQꢊWHPSHUDWXUHꢊSURJUDPPLQJꢊIURPꢊꢄꢁꢊWRꢊ
ꢍꢁꢁ&ꢊDWꢊDꢊUDWHꢊRIꢊꢉꢊGHJꢇPLQꢐꢊHOHFWURQꢊLPSDFWꢋꢊꢂꢁꢊH9ꢏꢌꢊ
7KHꢊPHOWLQJꢊSRLQWVꢊZHUHꢊGHWHUPLQHGꢊRQꢊDꢊ%RHWLXVꢊ
PHOWLQJꢊSRLQWꢊDSSDUDWXVꢌꢊ7KHꢊ,5ꢊVSHFWUDꢊZHUHꢊUHFRUGHGꢊ
LQꢊ.%UꢊRQꢊDꢊ85ꢃꢅꢁꢊVSHFWURPHWHUꢌꢊ7KHꢊ89ꢊVSHFWUDꢊZHUHꢊ
PHDVXUHGꢊRQꢊDꢊ6SHFRUGꢊ0ꢃꢄꢁꢁꢊVSHFWURSKRWRPHWHUꢊIURPꢊ
VROXWLRQVꢊ LQꢊ HWKDQROꢌꢊ 7KHꢊ +ꢊ DQGꢊ &ꢊ 105ꢊ VSHFWUDꢊ
ZHUHꢊREWDLQHGꢊRQꢊDꢊ%UXNHUꢊ$&ꢃꢅꢁꢁꢊLQVWUXPHQWꢊDWꢊꢊ
ꢅꢁꢁꢊ0+]ꢊIRUꢊ +ꢊDQGꢊꢑꢁꢌꢈꢍꢊ0+]ꢊIRUꢊ &ꢊIURPꢊVROXWLRQVꢊ
LQꢊ&'&O ꢊXVLQJꢊ706ꢊDVꢊLQWHUQDOꢊUHIHUHQFHꢌꢊ
7KHꢊQXPEHUꢊDQGꢊSRVLWLRQꢊRIꢊVLJQDOVꢊLQꢊWKHꢊ &ꢊ105ꢊ
VSHFWUDꢊFRUUHVSRQGꢊWRꢊWKHꢊDVVXPHGꢊVWUXFWXUHVꢌꢊ7KHꢊꢊ
+ꢊ105ꢊVSHFWUDꢊRIꢊ,,,D±,,,GꢊFRQWDLQHGꢊWZRꢃSURWRQꢊ
WULSOHWVꢊIURPꢊWKHꢊPHWK\OHQHꢊSURWRQVꢊRQꢊ& ꢊDQGꢊ& ꢊꢊ
ꢎ ꢊꢍꢌꢑꢀ±ꢄꢌꢁꢑꢊDQGꢊꢅꢌꢑꢁ±ꢍꢌꢁꢉꢊSSPꢋꢊUHVSHFWLYHO\ꢏꢊDQGꢊ
WKUHHꢃSURWRQꢊVLQJOHWVꢊIURPꢊWKHꢊꢄꢃPHWK\OꢊJURXSVꢊDWꢊꢊ
ꢊꢅꢌꢄꢁ±ꢅꢌꢄꢉꢊSSPꢌꢊ7KHꢊVSHFWUDꢊRIꢊ,,,FꢊDQGꢊ,,,GꢊDOVRꢊ
FRQWDLQHGꢊUHVRQDQFHꢊVLJQDOVꢊIURPꢊSURWRQVꢊLQꢊWKHꢊPHWKꢃ
R[\ꢊJURXSVꢊRQꢊ& ꢊDQGꢊ& ꢊLQꢊWKHꢊLVRTXLQROLQHꢊIUDJPHQWꢊ
ꢎ ꢊꢍꢌꢆꢑꢃꢍꢌꢑꢈꢊSSPꢏꢊDQGꢊRWKHUꢊVLJQDOVꢌꢊ
ꢀꢃ$ON\OꢃꢍꢋꢄꢃGLK\GURLVRTXLQROLQHVꢊ ,D±,Gꢊ ZHUHꢊ V\ Qꢃ
WKHVL]HGꢊE\ꢊWKHꢊ%LVFKOHU±1DSLHUDOVNLꢊUHDFWLRQꢊ>ꢀꢁꢋꢊꢅꢁ@ꢊ
E\ꢊ F\FORGHK\GUDWLRQꢊ RIꢊ WKHꢊ FRUUHVSRQGLQJꢊ SKHQHWK\Oꢃ
DPLGHVꢊ ZLWKꢊSRO\SKRVSKRULFꢊDFLGꢊꢎFRPSRXQGVꢊ ,DꢊDQGꢊ
,EꢏꢊRUꢊSKRVSKRU\OꢊFKORULGHꢊꢎ,FꢊDQGꢊ,Gꢏꢌꢊ$FHWRDFHWDWHVꢊ
,,D±,,Fꢊ ZHUHꢊ SUHSDUHGꢊ E\ꢊ DON\ODWLRQꢊ RIꢊ HWK\Oꢊ DFHWRꢃ
DFHWDWHꢊVRGLXPꢊVDOWꢊ>ꢅꢀ@ꢌꢊ&RPSRXQGꢊ,,GꢊZDVꢊREWDLQHGꢊ
E\ꢊWKHꢊ0LFKDHOꢊDGGLWLRQꢊRIꢊHWK\OꢊDFHWRDFHWDWHꢊWRꢊPHWK\Oꢊ
7KHꢊVWUXFWXUHꢊRIꢊFRPSRXQGVꢊ,,,ꢊZDVꢊILQDOO\ꢊFRQꢃ
ILUPHGꢊE\ꢊWKHꢊ12(ꢊVSHFWUDꢊ>ꢀꢑ@ꢌꢊ&RPSRXQGꢊ ,,,Dꢊ
GLVSOD\HGꢊGLUHFWꢊDQGꢊUHYHUVHꢊFRXSOLQJꢊEHWZHHQꢊꢀꢀꢃ+ꢊꢊ
ꢎ ꢊꢂꢌꢂꢈꢊSSPꢏꢊDQGꢊꢀꢃ+ꢊꢎ ꢊꢉꢌꢅꢅꢊSSPꢏꢋꢊDVꢊZHOOꢊDVꢊEHWZHHQꢊ
ꢉꢃ+ꢊꢎ ꢊꢄꢌꢁꢑꢊSSPꢏꢊDQGꢊꢄꢃ&+ ꢊꢎ ꢊꢅꢌꢄꢍꢊSSPꢏꢌꢊ2QꢊWKHꢊ
RWKHUꢊKDQGꢋꢊQRꢊFRXSOLQJꢊZDVꢊREVHUYHGꢊEHWZHHQꢊSURWRQVꢊ
UHVRQDWLQJꢊDWꢊ ꢊꢉꢌꢅꢅꢊDQGꢊꢅꢌꢄꢍꢊSSPꢋꢊZKLFKꢊFRXOGꢊEHꢊ
DVVLJQHGꢊWRꢊVWUXFWXUHꢊ,9ꢌꢊ/LNHZLVHꢋꢊFRPSRXQGꢊ,,,Eꢊ YLQ\OꢊNHWRQHꢊ>ꢅꢀ@ꢌꢊ
5866,$1ꢊꢊ-2851$/ꢊꢊ2)ꢊꢊ25*$1,&ꢊꢊ&+(0,675<ꢊꢊꢊ9ROꢌꢊꢊꢄꢀꢊꢊꢊ1Rꢌꢊꢊꢀꢅꢊꢊꢊꢅꢁꢁꢈꢊ